Why it is difficult to compare U.S. Navy SEALS with Army Rangers

Comments by Jim Campbell

August 5th, 2018

“Green Beret final Training Test: “It will look and sound like a war in 19 NC counties: It’s supposed to”

As the video below clearly demonstrates, it’s compare two different US special forces groups.

They  have their own unique mission sets.



SEAL’s don’t typically do what Green Berets do, and vice versa.

Not because they aren’t capable, but because their training and resources vary.

From Michael Yon’s “Up Close and Personal Diary.

August 5th, 2018



This was our final test to earn entry into Special Forces (Green Berets). It’s called Robin Sage.

The short version is that your 12 man A-Team receives a mission.

The team plans the mission which requires a great deal of thinking and finally memorization of details of the plan.

The team then conducts a “brief back” to the commander and other involved commanders and parties.



For Robin Sage, the mission is to parachute into the fictitious country of “Pineland.” (North Carolina has a lot of pine trees.)

So you fly in low at night, probably rumbling in a C-130 (we did, anyway), and jump into the darkness.

A lot of people get hurt on night parachute jumps. Unfortunately, for some people this jump ends their Green Beret career before it starts.

During my test, all teammates made the jump with weapon and heavy gear with no dramas.

Our team leader was a Canadian special forces captain. His codename for the mission was Maple. My codename was Miser.

 He was a great officer during SF training.

The first task is to get off the DZ (drop zone) stash the parachutes (really turn them in), and get away. Then make an encrypted call back with status.

(None of this is classified — it’s all in non-classified manuals.)

We then linked up with “guerrillas,” who in our case were Soldiers from non-combat jobs, so they had practically no combat training other than knowing their way around an M-16.

Whether they could hit something with it was another question.

Long story short: we train them for a short while, hit some targets, get very, very hungry, and work to keep them motivated.

For some “guerrillas” this is great fun to play with almost Green Berets, but for others it’s like a punishment assignment.

Making matters more interesting is that the broad area of the exercise is deeply populated by veterans of elite units. Green Berets, Delta Force, Rangers, various airborne units like 82nd, and some of them still like to play Soldier.

 Some of them take sport in trying to track you down to mess with you, and others to play guerrilla-friendly like they are on your side and give you information, but they might be lying so, you know, they make it realistic.

Our team did not encounter any vets but some did seem to be tracking a small patrol I was leading but we managed to avoid them.

Basically I was given a “G” (gorilla) or two to do a recon, and we came up on a muddy road that we had to cross. I said wait.

We ain’t crossing that muddy road to finish this recon.

We stopped in a hidden position were we could watch the road and I started checking the map for a way to cross without leaving obvious tracks.

While I was figuring what to do, a small car came down the muddy road and some guys got out and started walking the road — obviously looking for tracks!

I thought, either:

1) They live around there and are playing with us.

2) Are trying to steal our weapons (we are warned that militias stalk the students to steal their gear and rob them of weapons)

3) The Green Beret instructor set us up.

They got back in the car and left.

So, I called the mission and we quietly headed back to base.


Please see the entire article below.


That was a significant event that I had to report to the team leader immediately. Obviously someone was looking for us.

Anyway, I got my Green Beret shortly after that, and within a few days was in jail for murder! Unbelievable.

Anyway, that’s life. (Charges were dropped and I stayed in Green Berets four more years.)

It would be interesting to live around there and go hunting for A-Teams during Robin Sage. Great fun and makes it more realistic when the population engages.

Several years later, we did a similar exercise in the country of Luxembourg.

We were stationed in Germany but planned the mission in Spain, then flew to UK and landed and got straight into a blacked out bus and stayed in a “safe house” with blacked out windows.

Then parachuted at night into Luxembourg to conduct the mission. We linked up with “guerrillas” who were Luxembourgish Soldiers.

They had high morale so that part was easy.

We were told that there had been announcements in their media for farmers and others to help find us, and alert authorities if they caught a trace.

They were making it realistic.

Man were we hungry. I was ready to start stealing chickens.

Nobody is strong enough to carry all that gear and enough food.

An airplane parachuted supplies and so that was a happy night.

Then we got a radio message about some reactor accident in USSR.

Radiation was coming our way. Lovely. Chernobyl.



About JCscuba

I am firmly devoted to bringing you the truth and the stories that the mainstream media ignores. This site covers politics with a fiscally conservative, deplores Sharia driven Islam, and uses lots of humor to spiceup your day. Together we can restore our constitutional republic to what the founding fathers envisioned and fight back against the progressive movement. Obama nearly destroyed our country economically, militarily coupled with his racism he set us further on the march to becoming a Socialist State. Now it's up to President Trump to restore America to prominence. Republicans who refuse to go along with most of his agenda RINOs must be forced to walk the plank, they are RINOs and little else. Please subscribe at the top right and pass this along to your friends, Thank's I'm J.C. and I run the circus
This entry was posted in Why it is difficult to compare U.S. Navy SEALS with Army Rangers and tagged , , , , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.